Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Save this recipe on:

I can’t even begin to explain how this Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie changed the dessert game in my home. It was meant to be a casual treat, something simple and comforting, but the moment I took that first bite, I knew it was going to be a keeper. The creamy peanut butter filling is silky smooth, layered over a graham cracker crust with just the right crunch, then topped with clouds of whipped topping and a generous sprinkle of crushed peanut butter crumbs. Every texture, every flavor, is like a cozy hug.

This pie came together on a day when I craved something nostalgic, something that felt like a warm memory from a country kitchen. It took me right back to the kind of desserts you’d find cooling on the counter of a family farmhouse. And while I’m not Amish, I have deep respect for the richness and simplicity of their cooking traditions. This pie holds that kind of soul-satisfying magic. It’s old-fashioned in the best way, yet it still stuns with its creamy decadence.

One of the best things about this dessert is how effortlessly it impresses. Whether you’re preparing it for a holiday gathering, a weekend potluck, or just a weeknight indulgence, it never fails to draw compliments. It’s rich but not heavy, sweet without being overpowering, and the balance between the soft filling and the crunchy topping is perfection. I love pairing it with a cup of dark coffee or serving it as a surprise ending to a simple home-cooked meal.

Why You’ll Love This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

If you love peanut butter, you’re about to meet your new obsession. This pie delivers big on creamy texture and deep flavor, thanks to its rich peanut butter base. The graham cracker crust provides the ideal contrast, both in taste and texture. It’s also incredibly easy to make — no complicated steps or obscure ingredients. You don’t even need to bake it if you use a pre-made crust.

Another reason to fall in love with this recipe is its versatility. You can prep it ahead of time, making it perfect for entertaining or meal planning. The pie holds up beautifully in the fridge, and honestly, it might even taste better the next day.

And if you’re someone who appreciates no-fuss, classic desserts with big payoffs, this one is right up your alley. Looking for more classic treats? You might also love my Sopapilla Cheesecake Bars, Irresistible Funnel Cake Bites, or even the Peanut Butter Balls with Chocolate Rice Krispies.

Ingredients

Graham cracker crust: A crunchy and slightly sweet foundation that complements the creamy peanut butter filling beautifully. You can use a store-bought one or make it yourself with crushed graham crackers, sugar, and melted butter.

Creamy peanut butter: This is the soul of the pie. It brings a rich, nutty flavor and smooth consistency that’s essential to the filling.

Cream cheese: Adds tang and creaminess to balance the sweetness of the peanut butter. It helps stabilize the texture of the filling too.

Powdered sugar: Sweetens the filling without adding any graininess. It dissolves smoothly, ensuring a velvety texture.

Whipped topping: This is folded into the peanut butter mixture for an airy texture and also layered on top for a fluffy finish.

Milk: Just a splash to help blend everything together smoothly. It loosens the filling without making it runny.

Vanilla extract: A touch of warmth that enhances the flavors of the peanut butter and cream cheese.

Peanut butter crumbs or chopped peanuts: For that irresistible crunch on top, adding contrast in texture and boosting the peanut flavor.

How to Make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Step 1: Prepare the crust

Start by pressing your graham cracker crust into a pie dish if you’re using homemade. Chill it in the refrigerator while you prepare the filling. This helps set the base and makes it less crumbly when slicing.

Step 2: Mix the filling

In a mixing bowl, blend the cream cheese and peanut butter until smooth. Gradually beat in the powdered sugar, milk, and vanilla extract until everything is well combined and silky. Then gently fold in half of the whipped topping until fully incorporated.

Step 3: Assemble the pie

Spoon the peanut butter filling into the prepared crust and smooth the top with a spatula. Add the remaining whipped topping over the filling in a thick, even layer.

Step 4: Garnish and chill

Sprinkle the top with crushed peanut butter crumbs or chopped peanuts. Refrigerate the pie for at least 4 hours, or until it’s firm enough to slice cleanly. Overnight chilling is even better for flavor development.

Step 5: Serve and enjoy

Once chilled, slice and serve! Each bite should deliver creamy, nutty, crunchy, and sweet all at once.

Recipe Variations and Possible Substitutions

If you want to switch things up, try using crunchy peanut butter for a texture twist or swap it entirely for almond or cashew butter if you’re avoiding peanuts. Not a fan of graham cracker crust? A chocolate cookie crust adds a decadent edge that chocolate lovers will adore. For a lighter version, you can use reduced-fat cream cheese and light whipped topping without compromising much on flavor.

If you’re feeling adventurous, fold in mini chocolate chips or a swirl of melted chocolate into the filling. It adds extra richness and a bit of surprise in every bite. And if you like a salty-sweet balance, consider a pretzel crust for an unexpected crunch and savory edge.

Serving and Pairing Suggestions

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a showstopper all on its own, but if you want to elevate the experience, try drizzling a bit of chocolate or caramel sauce over each slice. A dollop of extra whipped cream or even a scoop of vanilla ice cream makes it feel downright celebratory.

As for drinks, this pie pairs beautifully with strong coffee or an ice-cold glass of milk. For a fancier twist, serve it with a chilled glass of dessert wine or a nutty-flavored liqueur. It’s also a wonderful finish to a classic comfort food dinner like Creamy Garlic Chicken Breasts or Shipwreck Dinner.

Storage and Reheating Tips

This pie stores wonderfully. Cover it tightly with plastic wrap or place it in an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 4-5 days. The crust may soften slightly over time, but the flavor only gets better.

Freezing is also an option. Wrap individual slices in plastic wrap and place them in a freezer-safe container. Thaw overnight in the fridge before serving. While it doesn’t need reheating, letting it sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes before serving can enhance the creaminess.

FAQs

How long does Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie last in the fridge?

This pie stays fresh in the fridge for up to 5 days if covered well. The texture and flavor hold up beautifully.

Can I freeze Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

Yes! Slice the pie, wrap the pieces in plastic, and store in an airtight container in the freezer. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before serving.

What type of peanut butter works best in Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

Creamy peanut butter is classic for a silky texture, but crunchy peanut butter or natural varieties can be used if you’re looking for more texture or fewer additives.

Do I have to bake the crust for Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

Not at all. A pre-made graham cracker crust works great and doesn’t need baking. If you’re making it from scratch, you can bake it for 8-10 minutes to firm it up, but it’s optional.

Related Recipe You’ll Like

If Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie won your heart, then you absolutely need to try my Chocolate Peanut Butter Dream Bars. They share the same sweet and creamy flavor base, with added layers of chocolatey indulgence. You might also enjoy the nostalgic charm of Sopapilla Cheesecake Bars or the perfectly poppable Irresistible Pecan Pie Bites. Each one brings a unique twist to dessert time.

Save and Share This Recipe for Later

Don’t lose this gem! Make sure to pin this Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie recipe on your favorite Pinterest board so it’s always just a click away when those sweet cravings hit. And if you love it as much as I do, share it with friends and family on Facebook or send it directly to someone who needs a new dessert obsession. There’s no better way to spread joy than with a slice of this pie!

Save this recipe on: